<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<user>
  <id type="integer">196811</id>
  <url>http://uservoice.com/users/196811-jonvanhala</url>
  <avatar_url>http://www.gravatar.com/avatar/0e319b11b5144b3be9fb95a305169cb4?default=http://uservoice.com/images/icons/default-avatar.jpg</avatar_url>
  <display_name>jonvanhala</display_name>
  <name deprecated="true">jonvanhala</name>
  <username deprecated="true">jonvanhala</username>
  <activity_score type="integer">0</activity_score>
  <idea_score type="integer">0</idea_score>
  <supported_suggestions type="array" deprecated="false">
<suggestion>
  <id type="integer">69416</id>
  <url>http://ideas.obamacto.org/pages/6111-obama-cto/suggestions/69416-repeal-the-digital-milennium-copyright-act-dmca-</url>
  <title>Repeal the Digital Milennium Copyright Act (DMCA)</title>
  <abstract>It is evident that the framers of the infamous Digital Millenium Copyright Act intended it to have a transformative effect on the public and legal perception of intellectual property. In the attempt...</abstract>
  <text>It is evident that the framers of the infamous Digital Millenium Copyright Act intended it to have a transformative effect on the public and legal perception of intellectual property. In the attempt to develop a fully-realized definition of what constitutes infringement, fair use, and the rights of users in the consumption of digital works, the DMCA has had quite the opposite effect by institutionalizing considerable legal ambiguity. The recent spat between the John McCain presidential campaign and YouTube has demonstrated that both practitioners of law and a leading supporter of the DMCA are no closer to understanding the controversial law than the general populace.

With so much confusion and abuse surrounding the DMCA, isn't it time we start over and take a fresh approach to intellectual property that doesn't irreconcilably tip the scales in favor of big media?</text>
  <closed_at nil="true"></closed_at>
  <vote_count type="integer">8851</vote_count>
  <comments_count type="integer">30</comments_count>
  <status nil="true"></status>
  <forum>
    <id type="integer">6111</id>
    <name>Obama CTO</name>
    <key deprecated="true">general</key>
  </forum>
  <response nil="true"></response>
  <created_by>
    <supporter>
      <user>
        <id type="integer">126815</id>
        <display_name>anonymous</display_name>
        <name deprecated="true">anonymous</name>
        <username deprecated="true">anonymous</username>
      </user>
    </supporter>
  </created_by>
  <created_at type="datetime">2008-11-12T14:40:08Z</created_at>
  <updated_at type="datetime">2008-11-12T14:40:08Z</updated_at>
  <page deprecated="true">
    <key>general</key>
  </page>
</suggestion>
<suggestion>
  <id type="integer">70185</id>
  <url>http://ideas.obamacto.org/pages/6111-obama-cto/suggestions/70185-rethink-corporate-copyright-ownership-for-the-21st-century</url>
  <title>rethink corporate copyright ownership for the 21st century</title>
  <abstract>The government should be proactive in supporting movements like creative commons, but also encourage copyright agencies to work together to make it easier to create innovative services based on...</abstract>
  <text>The government should be proactive in supporting movements like creative commons, but also encourage copyright agencies to work together to make it easier to create innovative services based on copywritten material, while properly paying royalties to the proper copyright holders.  Establishing a better standard for individuals without support by copyright agencies to defend their rights should also be considered.</text>
  <closed_at nil="true"></closed_at>
  <vote_count type="integer">14</vote_count>
  <comments_count type="integer">0</comments_count>
  <status nil="true"></status>
  <forum>
    <id type="integer">6111</id>
    <name>Obama CTO</name>
    <key deprecated="true">general</key>
  </forum>
  <response nil="true"></response>
  <created_by>
    <supporter>
      <user>
        <id type="integer">131094</id>
        <display_name>anonymous</display_name>
        <name deprecated="true">anonymous</name>
        <username deprecated="true">anonymous</username>
      </user>
    </supporter>
  </created_by>
  <created_at type="datetime">2008-11-13T01:37:46Z</created_at>
  <updated_at type="datetime">2008-11-13T01:37:46Z</updated_at>
  <page deprecated="true">
    <key>general</key>
  </page>
</suggestion>
<suggestion>
  <id type="integer">97016</id>
  <url>http://ideas.obamacto.org/pages/7070-suggest-topic/suggestions/97016-balance-ip-with-innovation-and-access</url>
  <title>Balance IP with innovation and access</title>
  <abstract>Let's get the IP issues in balance with American's desire for free/cheap content and access. </abstract>
  <text>Let's get the IP issues in balance with American's desire for free/cheap content and access. </text>
  <closed_at nil="true"></closed_at>
  <vote_count type="integer">1</vote_count>
  <comments_count type="integer">0</comments_count>
  <status nil="true"></status>
  <forum>
    <id type="integer">7070</id>
    <name>Suggest Topic</name>
    <key deprecated="true">suggest_topic</key>
  </forum>
  <response nil="true"></response>
  <created_by>
    <supporter>
      <user>
        <id type="integer">196811</id>
        <display_name>jonvanhala</display_name>
        <name deprecated="true">jonvanhala</name>
        <username deprecated="true">jonvanhala</username>
      </user>
    </supporter>
  </created_by>
  <created_at type="datetime">2009-01-01T20:33:29Z</created_at>
  <updated_at type="datetime">2009-01-01T20:33:29Z</updated_at>
  <page deprecated="true">
    <key>suggest_topic</key>
  </page>
</suggestion>
  </supported_suggestions>
  <created_at type="datetime">2009-01-01T20:31:11Z</created_at>
  <updated_at type="datetime">2009-01-09T14:20:16Z</updated_at>
</user>
